Allegation Misconduct
The Journal of Information Systems and Technology (JISTECH), published by Atha Publishing Globalindo, is committed to maintaining academic integrity, transparency, fairness, and accountability throughout the scholarly publishing process. The journal does not tolerate research or publication misconduct and handles all allegations seriously, impartially, and confidentially.
This policy applies to submitted manuscripts, manuscripts under peer review, published articles, and all individuals involved in the journal's editorial and publication processes. It is guided by the journal's publication ethics principles and the recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
Allegations of misconduct may include, but are not limited to:
- Plagiarism: Using another person's words, ideas, data, or work without appropriate acknowledgment.
- Data fabrication: Inventing research data, results, or findings that were not obtained through the reported research.
- Data falsification: Manipulating research materials, data, processes, or results in a manner that misrepresents the findings.
- Duplicate or redundant publication: Publishing substantially overlapping work without appropriate disclosure or acknowledgment.
- Improper authorship: Misrepresenting authorship, including ghost authorship, gift authorship, or unauthorized changes to the author list.
- Citation manipulation: Inappropriately adding citations to inflate citation counts or manipulate citation metrics.
- Undisclosed conflicts of interest: Failing to disclose relevant financial, professional, institutional, or personal interests.
- Peer review misconduct: Breaching review confidentiality, manipulating the peer review process, or misusing confidential manuscript information.
- Research ethics violations: Failing to obtain required ethical approval or informed consent, or violating applicable research ethics requirements.
- Copyright infringement: Using copyrighted or otherwise protected material without the necessary authorization or acknowledgment.
- Other serious publication violations: Any conduct that may compromise the reliability, originality, ethical acceptability, or integrity of scholarly work.
A similarity report, allegation, or procedural irregularity does not by itself establish misconduct. Each case must be assessed based on the available evidence and relevant circumstances.
Authors, reviewers, readers, researchers, institutions, and other concerned parties may report suspected research or publication misconduct to the JISTECH Editorial Office.
A report should, where possible, include:
- The title and bibliographic details of the manuscript or published article.
- A clear description of the suspected misconduct.
- Supporting evidence, such as relevant publications, source passages, data discrepancies, or documentation.
- The name and contact details of the complainant, if they are willing to provide them.
Reports should be submitted through the journal's official contact channels. Anonymous reports may also be considered when sufficient information is available for an initial assessment.
The journal will take reasonable steps to protect confidential information and the identity of complainants, subject to applicable legal and procedural requirements.
Upon receiving an allegation, the editor or an appropriately designated editorial representative will conduct an initial assessment to determine whether the concern is sufficiently specific and credible to warrant further examination.
The initial assessment may involve:
- Reviewing the allegation and supporting evidence.
- Checking the relevant manuscript, publication, references, or editorial records.
- Requesting clarification or additional documentation from the complainant when necessary.
- Determining whether the matter falls within the journal's responsibility or should be referred to another appropriate body.
If the allegation is unsupported, falls outside the journal's remit, or does not provide a reasonable basis for further action, the journal may close the matter with an appropriate record of its assessment. Where credible concerns remain, further examination will be conducted.
When an allegation warrants further examination, JISTECH will follow a fair, objective, and proportionate procedure, which may include:
- Preserving relevant records: Retaining manuscript versions, review reports, correspondence, publication files, and other available evidence.
- Seeking an explanation: Contacting the corresponding author or other relevant parties to request a response and supporting information.
- Evaluating the evidence: Assessing the available evidence objectively and seeking independent expert advice where necessary.
- Consulting relevant institutions: Referring serious research misconduct concerns to the author's institution, research organization, or other competent body when appropriate.
- Maintaining confidentiality: Sharing information only with individuals or organizations that have a legitimate role in addressing the matter.
- Recording the outcome: Documenting the assessment, significant communications, and editorial actions taken.
Universities, research institutions, and other competent bodies may have the authority and resources to conduct formal investigations. The journal's responsibility is to assess matters relevant to publication integrity, cooperate with appropriate investigations, and take necessary action concerning the scholarly record.
The person or persons concerned will normally be given an appropriate opportunity to respond to the allegation before a final adverse editorial decision is made, where doing so is consistent with confidentiality, legal requirements, and the integrity of the investigation.
All parties are expected to cooperate in good faith and provide accurate information. The journal will avoid premature conclusions and will not treat an allegation as proof of misconduct.
Editorial decisions will be based on the available evidence, the seriousness of the concern, the reliability of the research record, and applicable journal policies.
If a credible allegation concerns a manuscript that has not yet been published, the journal may take one or more of the following actions, depending on the circumstances:
- Request clarification, supporting evidence, or corrections from the authors.
- Suspend the editorial process while the matter is assessed.
- Request an independent review or further expert assessment.
- Reject the manuscript if serious ethical or scholarly deficiencies are established.
- Refer the matter to the relevant institution or competent authority where appropriate.
A manuscript will not be rejected solely because an unsubstantiated allegation has been made. The journal will consider the evidence and provide a fair assessment before deciding on the appropriate action.
When an allegation concerns an already published article, JISTECH will assess whether the concern affects the reliability, originality, ethical acceptability, or integrity of the published work.
Depending on the findings and available evidence, the journal may:
- Publish a correction when the issue can be addressed without invalidating the principal findings or conclusions.
- Publish an expression of concern when a significant issue remains unresolved and readers need to be informed.
- Retract the article when the evidence establishes that the publication is seriously unreliable or otherwise warrants retraction.
- Notify the relevant institution or competent authority when appropriate.
- Take other proportionate editorial action consistent with publication ethics and applicable requirements.
Corrections, expressions of concern, and retraction notices will explain the reason for the action as clearly as appropriate and will be linked to the affected article whenever possible. The journal seeks to preserve the transparency and integrity of the scholarly record.
Allegations involving editors, reviewers, or other journal personnel will be handled impartially and, where necessary, by an independent person who is not implicated in the allegation.
If an editor has a conflict of interest or is directly involved in the matter, that editor must not control the assessment or decision. The matter may be referred to another qualified editor or an appropriate representative of the publisher.
Allegations involving peer review may include breaches of confidentiality, misuse of unpublished work, undisclosed conflicts of interest, inappropriate reviewer conduct, or manipulation of the review process. The journal may consult relevant institutions or other appropriate bodies when warranted.
JISTECH will handle allegations and investigation records confidentially to the extent reasonably possible. Information will be disclosed only when necessary to assess the allegation, protect the integrity of the publication process, cooperate with a legitimate investigation, or comply with applicable legal requirements.
The journal does not condone retaliation against individuals who raise concerns in good faith or cooperate with an investigation. Reports must, however, be made responsibly and should not knowingly contain false or misleading information.
Confidentiality does not prevent the journal from publishing an appropriate correction, expression of concern, or retraction notice when necessary to protect the scholarly record.
Following assessment or investigation, the editor will determine the appropriate editorial action within the journal's authority. The decision may take into account the seriousness of the misconduct, the strength of the evidence, the response of the parties concerned, any institutional findings, and the potential effect on the published scholarly record.
Possible outcomes include closing the case without further action, requesting corrections or clarification, rejecting a manuscript, issuing a post-publication notice, or referring the matter to a relevant institution or competent authority.
The journal will not impose disciplinary measures beyond its authority. Any institutional or professional sanctions are matters for the relevant institution or competent body. Editorial decisions concerning misconduct will be made independently of commercial, personal, or other improper influence.
JISTECH may review and update this policy to reflect developments in publication ethics, applicable regulations, and recognized scholarly publishing standards.
This policy should be read together with the journal's Publication Ethics, Peer Review Process, Copyright and Licensing Policy, and Correction and Retraction Policy.
For questions or to report suspected research or publication misconduct, please contact the editorial office of the Journal of Information Systems and Technology (JISTECH).
Email: athapublishingglobalindo@gmail.com
Publisher: Atha Publishing Globalindo

